| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Original Article |
1 Division of General Surgery, Mayo Clinic, 13400 East Shea Boulevard, Scottsdale, Arizona 85259
2 Division of Anatomic Pathology, Mayo Clinic, 200 First Street SW, Rochester, Minnesota 55905
3 Division of Biostatistics, Mayo Clinic, 13400 East Shea Boulevard, Scottsdale, Arizona 85259
4 Division of Gastroenterologic and General Surgery, Mayo Clinic, 200 First Street SW, Rochester, Minnesota 55905
Correspondence: Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Barbara A. Pockaj, MD; E-mail: pockaj.barbara{at}mayo.edu.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: We performed a retrospective review of all patients (19852000) with a pathologic diagnosis of breast cancer metastatic to the gastrointestinal tract or peritoneum. Patients were categorized into three groups: those with gastrointestinal metastasis, carcinomatosis, or both.
Results: Of 73 patients, 23 (32%) had gastrointestinal metastasis only, 32 (44%) had carcinomatosis only, and 18 (25%) had both. The median age at initial breast cancer diagnosis was 55 years. The mean interval between the primary diagnosis and metastatic presentation was 7 years. Sites of gastrointestinal metastases included the esophagus (8%), stomach (28%), small intestine (19%), and colon and rectum (45%). Infiltrating lobular carcinoma represented 34 (64%) of the 53 gastrointestinal metastases. The median overall survival after diagnosis was 28 months. Palliative surgical intervention in 47 patients (64%) did not affect overall survival. Some survival benefit may have accrued to select patients with gastrointestinal metastasis who underwent surgical palliation (44 vs. 9 months). Advanced age at diagnosis and gastric metastases had a negative effect on survival, whereas treatment with systemic chemotherapy or tamoxifen had a positive effect on survival.
Conclusions: Gastrointestinal metastasis occurred more often in patients with invasive lobular carcinoma. Surgical intervention did not significantly extend overall survival but may be considered in a select group of patients.
Key Words: Gastrointestinal metastasis Carcinomatosis Breast cancer Palliative surgery Survival
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Gastrointestinal (GI) tract metastasis and carcinomatosis from primary breast cancer are rare. One autopsy series reported an occurrence rate of 8% to 35%.59 The metastatic patterns of lobular and ductal carcinoma have been reported to differ considerably. Most series report a greater propensity for lobular carcinoma to metastasize to the GI tract, gynecological organs, or peritoneum.10,11 Most reports in the medical literature on the clinical presentation and outcome of patients with GI metastasis, carcinomatosis, or both consist of individual case reports or small series.
This study was undertaken to review the clinical presentation, treatment, and outcome in patients with breast cancer metastatic to the GI tract or peritoneum. We also compared the metastatic patterns of infiltrating lobular carcinoma and infiltrating ductal carcinoma. In addition, we analyzed the factors associated with prolonged survival in this unique group of patients.
| PATIENTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A specific histological subtype was not specified in 30 % of the initial breast cancer pathologic diagnoses. Pathologic slides from these patients were reviewed and subtyped by a single pathologist with expertise in breast carcinoma. Pathologic criteria for the diagnosis of invasive lobular carcinoma included single-file strands of infiltrating small tumor cells with relatively little nuclear pleomorphism, loosely dispersed throughout the fibrous matrix, with or without the presence of signet-ring cells. Pathologic criteria for diagnosis of invasive ductal carcinoma included tumor cells disposed in tubules, cords, solid cell nests, or aggregate masses with invasion of the surrounding stroma. Original breast cancer presentations were staged according to the 2003 American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system.
Median survival was calculated for the overall study group and for the three subgroups. The calculations were performed by using Kaplan-Meier estimates. Survival time periods were compared for patients who had palliative surgery versus those who did not, and statistical significance was assessed by using Wilcoxon statistics. Several variables were also tested by Cox multivariate analysis for their effect on survival.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Staging and histological classification of the initial breast cancer in each group are listed in Table 1
. Most of the 73 patients initially presented with stage II cancer according to the 2003 American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system: stage I, 14%; stage II, 45%; stage III, 8%; and stage IV, 12%. We were unable to stage 15 patients (21%) because of unknown tumor size, lymph node status, or both.
Treatment at the time of diagnosis reflected the standard therapy for breast cancer in the 1970s and 1980s. Seventy-two of the 73 patients had surgical procedures for 81 invasive breast cancers. Fifty-seven patients (79%) were treated with a modified radical mastectomy. Twenty-two patients (31%) received adjuvant systemic chemotherapy, 23 (32%) received adjuvant hormonal therapy, and 14 (19%) received postmastectomy irradiation.
The mean interval between the primary diagnosis of breast cancer and GI metastatic presentation was 7 years. Twelve patients (16%) were found to have GI or peritoneal metastatic disease at the time of their breast cancer diagnosis. The clinical presentation of GI or peritoneal metastatic disease varied substantially. Most signs and symptoms were nonspecific. Abdominal pain was the most common symptom, followed by bloating, melena, GI hemorrhage, bowel obstruction, nausea and vomiting, early satiety, dysphagia, weight loss, anemia or fatigue, and palpable mass (Table 2
). Metastatic disease was found in asymptomatic patients (5%) during routine surveillance. GI metastasis or carcinomatosis was the first manifestation of metastatic disease in 32 patients (44%). In this subset of patients, the mean disease-free interval from primary diagnosis to metastatic diagnosis was 8.8 years.
|
|
Two patients presenting with right upper quadrant pain 3 and 6 years after diagnosis were assumed to have cholecystitis on the basis of their sonographical findings. A third patient with assumed choledocholithiasis 12 years after a breast cancer diagnosis presented with right upper quadrant abdominal pain and ultrasonographical and radiographical evidence of a dilated common bile duct and intrahepatic ducts. All three patients underwent open cholecystectomy, during which metastatic disease was discovered.
Metastatic breast cancer was mentioned in the differential diagnosis of four of the five patients thought to have ovarian cancer. One patient with a disease-free interval of 13 years, who presented with 3 months of abdominal pain, a 20-pound weight loss, and radiographical evidence of a complex cystic ovarian mass, was considered to have ovarian cancer until the total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy pathologic specimens were evaluated.
A total of 53 GI metastases were found in 41 patients with GI metastases (groups 1 and 3). Ten patients (24%) had metastases to two or more GI sites. The distribution by histological findings is listed in Table 4
. The most common site of metastasis was the colon or rectum, followed by the stomach, small intestine, or esophagus. GI metastases in patients with invasive lobular carcinoma outnumbered 2-fold those found in patients with invasive ductal carcinoma.
|
After the discovery of GI metastatic disease, most patients were treated with systemic chemotherapy (59%) or hormonal therapy (56%). Very few patients were treated with radiotherapy (8%). Surgical palliation in the form of GI resection, debulking, or GI bypass was performed in 47 patients (64%). Seven patients (10%) had exploratory laparotomy with immediate closure because of widespread disease. The indication for surgical intervention in these patients was primarily for obstructive symptoms or mass effect. Of the patients who underwent surgical palliation, the following operations were performed: 28 GI resections with primary anastomosis, 3 GI resections with ostomy, 8 GI bypasses, 13 diverting ostomies, 10 extensive debulkings of metastatic disease, and 17 bilateral salpingo-oophorectomies.
The overall median survival after diagnosis of GI or peritoneal metastatic disease was 28 months (Fig. 1
). The overall subgroup median survival was 29, 17, and 32 months for groups 1, 2, and 3, respectively (Table 3
). Twenty-four patients (33%) survived >30 months and had a median survival of 84 months. Overall, advanced age, gastric metastases, and systemic or hormonal therapy after diagnosis of metastatic disease had a significant effect on patient survival (Table 5
). A 1-year increase in age led to a greater chance of death (odds ratio [OR], 1.03; P = .02). Systemic chemotherapy or hormonal therapy was found to have a positive effect on survival (OR, .39; P = .003). By GI site, gastric metastases were found to have a negative effect on survival (OR, 2.32; P = .02). The following factors did not affect survival significantly: stage at primary diagnosis, adjuvant chemotherapy or radiotherapy at primary diagnosis, interval from primary diagnosis to GI or peritoneal metastatic diagnosis, GI metastasis as the first metastatic recurrence, GI metastasis as the only site of recurrence, or lobular versus ductal histological findings.
|
|
Overall, surgical palliation had no statistically significant effect on the median length of survival (28 vs. 26 months; P = .31). However, patients with only GI metastasis who underwent palliative surgical intervention tended to have a much more prolonged median survival (44 vs. 9 months; P = .1). The difference in median values between the two groups, however, was not great enough to exclude the possibility that the difference was due to random sampling variability or patient selection (Table 3
).
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A landmark study by Borst and Ingold10 reporting the metastatic patterns of invasive lobular carcinoma versus invasive ductal carcinoma was published in 1993. The series analyzed 2604 cases of breast cancer with subsequent metastatic disease over an 18-year period. When compared with other breast cancer subtypes, infiltrating lobular carcinoma was found to metastasize more frequently to the GI tract, gynecological organs, peritoneum, retroperitoneum, adrenal glands, or bone marrow. In this large series, only 17 patients (<1%) were found to have metastasis to the GI tract: this reflects the rare nature of metastases to this site.
The largest case series in the medical literature that reports GI metastasis secondary to breast cancer was published in 1968 by Asch et al.7 This autopsy series reported 52 cases of GI metastasis secondary to breast cancer. The distribution of these metastases was as follows: esophagus (25%), stomach (25%), small intestine (28%), colon (19%), and rectum (4%). There was no mention of the primary histological subtype in this series.
Taal and colleagues16,17 from the Netherlands Cancer Institute published reports in 1992 of two series of patients with GI metastasis secondary to breast cancer. The first series presented 27 patients with breast carcinoma metastatic to the stomach.16 The second series presented 17 patients with colorectal metastases secondary to breast cancer. Both reports noted a greater frequency of primary infiltrating lobular carcinoma (88%) compared with infiltrating ductal carcinoma (74%).17 Eight years later, these authors published a subsequent report that expanded the series of breast carcinoma meta-static to the stomach to 51 cases.18 Infiltrating lobular carcinoma again outnumbered infiltrating ductal carcinoma (72%). These case reports and other well-known articles are listed in Table 6
.
|
For patients with a history of breast cancer and a new diagnosis of a GI neoplasm, Schwarz and colleagues1 have recommended making a histopathological and immunohistochemical comparison between the initial primary breast cancer and the GI neoplasm. Immunohistochemical markers for the estrogen receptor, gross cystic disease fluid protein, and the differential expression of cytokeratin 7 and 20 can facilitate an accurate diagnosis and prompt initiation of appropriate antineoplastic therapy.15,21
The present study from Mayo Clinic is the largest nonautopsy case series of women with breast cancer metastatic to the GI tract and peritoneum in the United States. This study differs from other clinical studies of metastatic breast cancer in that it focused on all sites of GI tract metastases and included an evaluation of patients with carcinomatosis. Forty-one patients with GI metastasis secondary to breast cancer presented with 53 metastatic sites. Ten patients presented with two or more sites of GI metastasis. Most GI metastases were found in the colon and rectum (45%) or stomach (28%).
Favorable prognostic features regarding survival after the diagnosis of metastatic disease were the use of systemic chemotherapy (P = .004) and the use of systemic chemotherapy or hormonal therapy (P = .003). Poor prognostic features included advanced age and gastric metastatic disease. The finding of advanced age as a poor prognostic factor may be due to the possibility that some patients were not given the option of chemotherapy because of advanced age.
Overall, surgical intervention did not have a significant effect on the median length of survival (28 vs. 26 months). Patients with GI metastasis only who underwent palliative surgical intervention tended to have a more prolonged median survival (44 vs. 9 months). This difference, however, was not statistically significant, and the observed difference in survival may have been due to other factors, such as biased patient selection for palliative surgical intervention. Surgery has a role in palliative care for relief of symptoms and in supportive care of the patient with incurable disease. The decision-making process of whether to treat these patients surgically should be based on the clinical presentation and symptoms, the availability of chemotherapeutic options, and a quality-of-life discussion.22
One limitation of our study is that it investigated only women who had a pathologic diagnosis of metastatic disease. It is possible that a larger percentage of GI metastasis or carcinomatosis developed in women with breast cancer and that they were diagnosed radiographically rather than with a diagnostic pathologic specimen. This group of patients is somewhat unique, as reflected by their delayed clinical presentation of intra-abdominal metastatic disease (7 years). Most patients presented with vague symptoms. Because of the delayed clinical presentation and vague symptoms, all patients underwent biopsy to confirm the diagnosis. The diagnostic difficulty in these patients is demonstrated by the fact that 21% were thought to have a different disease process, and 11% patients did not receive a diagnosis until they had exploratory laparotomy. The patients who presented with intra-abdominal disease early after their original diagnosis or the patients who had multiple other sites of metastatic disease consistent with a primary breast cancer would probably not be captured in our study. Finally, some GI metastasis, in particular, metastasis to the mid portion of the small intestine, may have been inaccessible endoscopically.
In summary, the diagnosis of GI metastasis or carcinomatosis secondary to breast cancer is rare. Diagnosis is often difficult because of a prolonged disease-free interval before metastatic presentation. Despite the much greater prevalence of infiltrating ductal carcinoma among women with breast cancer, GI metastasis occurred more often in patients with invasive lobular carcinoma than in patients with invasive ductal carcinoma. This finding concurs with those of other series, which have reported a greater prevalence of lobular carcinoma metastatic to the GI tract.
The median overall survival in our patients after a diagnosis of GI metastasis or carcinomatosis was 28 months, which is consistent with the median survival of all women with metastatic disease secondary to breast cancer (range, 2436 months).23 Surgical intervention did not significantly extend overall survival and should be considered palliative. Although it was not statistically significant, there was some improved survival for patients with GI metastasis who underwent surgical palliation (44 vs. 9 months).
Received for publication March 18, 2004. Accepted for publication May 18, 2005.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |