| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
ORIGINAL ARTICLES |
From the Department of Surgery (CC, HC), University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, Madison, Wisconsin; and the Departments of Surgery (WHW) and Pathology (RU), Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland.
Correspondence: Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Herbert Chen, MD, H4/750 Clinical Science Center, 600 Highland Ave., Madison, WI 53792; Fax: 608-263-7652; E-mail: chen{at}surgery.wisc.edu
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: To investigate the utility of FNA, data from 23 consecutive patients with primary malignant thyroid lymphoma evaluated at the Johns Hopkins Hospital from July 1985 to April 2000 were analyzed.
Results: Patients were categorized into two groups: those diagnosed before 1993 (group 1, n = 12) and those diagnosed after 1993 (group 2, n = 11). Although patients in group 1 were slightly older, there were no other differences between the groups with regard to sex, tumor grade, or tumor stage. Although no patient in group 1 was successfully diagnosed by FNA alone, seven patients (63%) in group 2 were diagnosed solely by FNA (P = .019,
2 analysis). Therefore, all 12 patients in group 1, but only 4 of 11 patients in group 2, required open surgical biopsy.
Conclusions: Primary thyroid lymphoma is an uncommon malignancy usually treated nonsurgically once the diagnosis is established. In most patients with malignant lymphoma of the thyroid, FNA, should obviate the need for open surgical biopsy.
Key Words: Thyroid lymphoma Fine-needle aspiration Diagnosis Cytology
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Advances in immunophenotypic analysis, including immunohistochemistry and flow cytometry, have had a tremendous effect on the diagnosis of systemic lymphomas. Once considered a complement to open surgical biopsy, FNA alone has a reported accuracy rate of 80% to 100% in the diagnosis of systemic lymphomas because, in large part, of the addition of immunophenotyping studies.1418 We suspect that the addition of immunophenotyping has had a parallel effect on the FNA diagnosis of thyroid lymphomas. To investigate the utility of FNA in the diagnosis of primary thyroid lymphoma, we reviewed our experience with primary thyroid lymphoma over a 15-year period.
| METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2 analysis, and the Mann-Whitney rank-sum test when appropriate (SPSSTM software, SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). Significance was defined as a P value of < .05. | RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Patients in group 2 had a diagnosis of thyroid lymphoma established by FNA nearly two thirds of the time; this was a statistically significant difference compared with group 1 (Table 2). More important, of the eight patients who had an FNA performed in group 2, seven (88%) were diagnosed with thyroid lymphoma on FNA alone, with no further invasive diagnostic testing necessary. In the only patient who had a nondiagnostic FNA, the result was found to be suggestive of lymphoma but needed confirmation by open biopsy, which demonstrated a low-grade MALT lymphoma.
Six (75%) of eight patients in group 2 who had an FNA underwent further analysis of the aspirate by flow cytometry or immunohistochemical staining. Two patients did not have further analysis because of an insufficient amount of tissue. It is interesting to note that both FNAs were diagnostic of thyroid lymphoma solely on the basis of cytomorphological characteristics. All seven patients diagnosed with thyroid lymphoma by FNA had a clinical course consistent with the diagnosis and received treatment based solely on the FNA results. Of the three patients in group 2 who did not have an FNA performed and required more invasive procedures for diagnosis, one had an open biopsy, one had a lobectomy, and one had a total thyroidectomy. For those patients undergoing operative procedures, eight had an open biopsy, four had thyroid lobectomies, one had a total thyroidectomy, one had a subtotal thyroidectomy, and one had a core-needle biopsy.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The role of the surgeon in the management of thyroid lymphoma is diminishing. Less than 25 years ago, the standard of care for thyroid lymphoma was radical resection, because the disease was thought to be a form of anaplastic thyroid carcinoma. Thyroid lymphomas would often present quite dramatically, with a rapidly growing neck mass and symptoms of dysphagia, dysphonia, dyspnea, and even tracheal compression/obstruction in a manner similar to anaplastic carcinoma.1 In the past, surgeons would perform radical thyroidectomies,24 the treatment of choice at that time for anaplastic carcinoma.6,25 As the benefit of chemotherapy and radiotherapy over surgery in thyroid lymphoma became evident,9,12,19,2631 the need for surgical intervention diminished, although invasive procedures were still necessary to establish the diagnosis.23,32 With the eventual introduction of FNA in the diagnosis of systemic lymphomas, several authors began to discuss whether the technique could be used for thyroid lymphomas and obviate the need for any surgical intervention.19,28,33,34 In this report, our data demonstrate that the majority of patients with thyroid lymphoma can be diagnosed by FNA alone, especially when it is combined with flow cytometry and immunohistochemical analysis.
The advances in FNA diagnosis of primary thyroid lymphoma have mirrored those of systemic lymphoma. As cytopathologists gained experience making the diagnosis of nodal lymphoma on FNA, that expertise translated into diagnosing lymphoma on FNA aspirates obtained from thyroid masses. Additionally, part of the improved comfort level of pathologists to make the diagnosis of lymphoma is due to the ever-evolving lymphoma classification system. In its latest adaptation, the revised European-American classification of lymphoid neoplasms, there is a marked de-emphasis of tissue architecture and an increased value placed on individual cell morphology in conjunction with immunophenotypingideal for diagnostic cytopathology.14,35 Already, large retrospective studies have confirmed the ability of the revised European-American classification of lymphoid neoplasms classification system to identify major types of lymphoma with a high reproducibility rate.36,37
Therefore, part of the improvement in the ability to diagnose thyroid lymphoma on FNA aspirates after 1993 is due to the improved comfort level of cytopathologists in making the diagnosis; this is reflected by the fact that the two patients in group 2 who did not receive additional immunophenotyping analysis nevertheless were diagnosed with thyroid lymphoma on FNA alone, whereas none of the four patients in group 1 who had an FNA could be diagnosed conclusively. Seven of eight patients in group 2 were correctly diagnosed with thyroid lymphoma by FNA without the need for additional tissue acquisition by more invasive techniques. This 88% sensitivity rate matches the 80% to 90% rates reported for FNA in systemic lymphoma.1418 The only nondiagnostic FNA in group 2 occurred in a patient with a low-grade MALT tumor, which can be a difficult diagnosis even on an open surgical biopsy specimen. The FNA result was suggestive of lymphoma, and the MALT tumor was confirmed by open biopsy. It is interesting to note that low-grade lymphoma was diagnosed by FNA in group 2 on two other occasions, including one MALT tumor, suggesting that low-grade lymphomas can be diagnosed by FNA alone, although with less consistency.
Another large factor in the ability to diagnose thyroid lymphomas by FNA is the advances in ancillary techniques, immunophenotyping in particular, in the cytopathologic diagnosis. In the systemic lymphoma literature, a series by Kaleem et al.38 reported that with use of cytomorphological analysis alone, a definitive diagnosis of lymphoma was made in only 18% of cases, but once the results of immunophenotyping were factored in, a definitive diagnosis was possible in 88% of cases; only 12% remained less than definitive.35 In primary thyroid lymphoma, initial series looking at FNA in thyroid lymphoma had less than spectacular results. Matsuda et al.39 reported a series of 119 patients with thyroid lymphoma and found that FNA was suggestive of lymphoma in 78% of the cases but could not be confirmed without open biopsy. Skarsgard et al.12 reported that FNA was suggestive but not diagnostic 56% of the time in their series of 27 patients. Several other series have had similar results,25,32,34 and it is important to note that none of these series incorporated any additional immunophenotyping studies, such as flow cytometry or immunohistochemistry on FNA samples.
This series is one of the first in which FNA in combination with immunophenotyping has been successfully demonstrated to diagnose thyroid lymphoma, confirming the diagnosis 88% of the time without the need for further invasive procedures. The diagnosis was made with a combination of cytomorphogenic analysis demonstrating monomorphic lymphoid cells and immunophenotyping analysis indicating B-cell lineage of lymphocytes with characteristic tumor clonality. The diagnosis was confirmed with immunohistochemical staining with CD20, restricted expression of
or
light chains, immunoglobulin gene rearrangements, or a combination of these.9,13,40,41 Additionally, DNA aneuploidy and increased proliferated activity on FNA are characteristic findings in thyroid lymphoma.40,42
The benefits of diagnosing thyroid lymphoma with FNA are obvious, including the ease, safety, rapidity, and potential cost-effectiveness of the procedure compared with those of open biopsy or thyroidectomy. Additionally, most patients with a thyroid mass will have an FNA performed as part of their standard work-up. There are several potential difficulties, however. The technique is extremely operator dependentinadequate sampling leads to false negatives and insufficient material for flow cytometry. Therefore, we recommend three or four separate needle passes until the specimen is cloudy, making multiple passes from different areas of the lesion, and performing a repeat FNA when necessary before proceeding with an open biopsy. Fortunately, the technique of FNA is one that many physicians are comfortable with. The proficiency of pathologists at confirming a diagnosis of thyroid lymphoma on FNAs, however, will also depend on their level of expertise in performing complex immunophenotyping procedures on FNA aspiratesa capability that many pathology laboratories may not have. FNA, even in the best of hands, is limited by potential sampling error and artifact. In such cases, and in any instance in which a diagnosis is equivocal on FNA, open biopsy is recommended. Open biopsy is a technique that surgeons are comfortable with, and when it is performed under local anesthesia, it poses minimal morbidity to the patient. Therefore, FNA should not be considered a replacement for open biopsy but rather an additional diagnostic test in the work-up of thyroid lymphoma that can be performed in the office, before the need for an open surgical biopsy.
Once considered a surgical disease, the current management of thyroid lymphoma has evolved to the point where an invasive procedure is required only for diagnosis or palliation. The ability to use fine-needle biopsy for diagnosis obviates the need for open biopsy or lobectomy and allows for early treatment, which can improve survival.13 The success of our pathologists in diagnosing primary thyroid lymphoma on FNA has rendered it an essentially nonsurgical disease; it minimizes patient discomfort, maximizes safety to the patient, and avoids a delay in the initiation of therapy.
Received for publication March 16, 2001. Accepted for publication September 20, 2001.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
D. Y. Greenblatt, T. Woltman, J. Harter, J. Starling, E. Mack, and H. Chen Fine-Needle Aspiration Optimizes Surgical Management in Patients With Thyroid Cancer Ann. Surg. Oncol., June 1, 2006; 13(6): 859 - 863. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. T. Hehn, T. M. Grogan, and T. P. Miller Utility of Fine-Needle Aspiration As a Diagnostic Technique in Lymphoma J. Clin. Oncol., August 1, 2004; 22(15): 3046 - 3052. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. A. Callcut, S. M. Selvaggi, E. Mack, O. Ozgul, T. Warner, and H. Chen The Utility of Frozen Section Evaluation for Follicular Thyroid Lesions Ann. Surg. Oncol., January 1, 2004; 11(1): 94 - 98. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. S. Sippel, P. G. Gauger, P. Angelos, N. W. Thompson, E. Mack, and H. Chen Palliative Thyroidectomy for Malignant Lymphoma of the Thyroid Ann. Surg. Oncol., November 1, 2002; 9(9): 907 - 911. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |